First off, what a horrible opening on ESPN2. Announcers Dave Flemming and Danny Kanell started by discussing the college football playoff, which had nothing to do with Tulane-Cincy but furthers the ESPN hype machine for an event it has the TV rights to, and then Kanell said he had never seen anything like the "quarterback carousel" at Tulane and Cincinnati.
Huh? Gunner Kiel hurt his ribs for Cincy in his previous game and was replaced by Munchy Legaux. Crazy! Tanner Lee suffered a shoulder injury against Rutgers and was replaced by Devin Powell, who then lost his job to last year's starter, Nick Montana. Wild, wacky stuff? Well, not really. It was just two teams having injuries to starting QBs, and one of the two teams going back to its starter from 2013 after that injury. Pretty normal.
I will look at the seven big plays Tulane's defense gave up against the Bearcats--six plays of 20 yards or more plus the 18-yard back-breaking touchdown that gave Cincinnati a 31-14 lead after Tulane had scored TDs on its first two second half possessions.
Last year, Tulane gave up 7 big plays (20 or more yards) to East Carolina, then did not give up more than four in the last six games or more than three in the last five. The defense has been a lot more prone to killer gains this season, as evidenced by Halloween night.
PLAY NO 1: Rod Moore 20-yard gain on Cincinnati's first play after sacking Tanner Lee on fourth-and-goal from the 2.
--Sean Wilson got engulfed, allowing Moore to run right up the middle when end Tyler Gilbert could not get to him near the line of scrimmage. Sam Scofield made a heck of a shoestring tackle as Moore was accelerating to trip him up. Otherwise, it would have been a footrace between Moore and Lorenzo Doss to the end zone for what might have been an 87-yard touchdown. It looks like Doss would have gotten him, but it's no sure thing. Nico Marley ran into the wrong gap, taking himself out of the play immediately as he went wide while the play went up the middle.
ANALYSIS: There has been too much of this year with the Tulane D. Wilson is a true freshman, so he is going to get blocked on some plays, but Marley needed to be more disciplined on that play and the rest of the defense, except for Scofield, appeared slow to react.
Quick aside: Tyler Gilbert's targeting call was legit two plays later. He did nothing malicious, but that's the rule. He hit Legeau with his helmet.He could have been called for unsportsmanlike conduct for taking his helmet off after the call, but the officials showed some discretion there.
PLAY NO. 2: Middle screen to wide receiver Johnny Holton for 30 yards.
--Holton lined up wide left, ran toward the middle of the field to catch the ball and benefited from a good block on Doss from a receiver and a so-so block on Brandon LeBeau by a guard that still kept him out of the play. Once again, Marley got out of position without being blocked. He looked like he wanted to run around the outside of an offensive lineman, and by the time he realized the play was going by him to the middle, it was too late. Scofield took a bad angle and let Holton get by him, too, before the speedy Taurean Nixon wrestled him to the ground with a nice tackle from behind.
ANALYSIS: This was a well-executed play. Darion Monroe blitzed and had no chance to get to the quarterback or get to the receiver. Not sure Doss would have had a chance without the block, but Marley and Scofield could have kept it from being a 30-yard gain. Nixon kept it from being a likely touchdown. Parry Nickerson would have gotten his hands on Holton, but tackling is not his forte. Marley, by the way, made an outstanding tackle on the next play after lining up to blitz, reacting quickly to stop a runner from getting downfield.
PLAY NO. 3: Rod Moore breaks five tackles on a 61-yard run to the 5.
--Moore took a handoff in the shotgun and immediately cut to his left, getting past tackle Tanzel Smart, who was lined up as a right end in a 3-man front. He ran through an arm tackle by linebacker Eric Thomas, then broke a weak tackle attempt by Doss, who had the leverage to bring him to the ground. It was off to the races from there, Scofield and Darion Monroe tried to bring him down at the Cincy 45, Scofield did not have a clean shot at him, but Monroe did, and Moore bounced off his hit like it was nothing and kept going. He cut around Taurean Nixon at the 30, bounced off lame tackle attempts by LeBeau and Nickerson around the 10 and finally was dragged down by Monroe, who showed good second-effort, at the 5.
ANALYSIS: this might have been the nadir for the Tulane D this year. Check out Doss' effort to tackle him at the end of the play after already missing once near the line. He caught up to him near the 10, then jumped out of the way of LeBeau and Monroe instead of taking a shot and ran with his back to the play while Monroe struggled to bring Moore down. Awful. Doss is a stand-up, full-effort guy, but not on that play. You could make a case that seven tackles were missed on one play. Wow. They have to play harder than that.
Tulane played well to force Cincy into a third-and-goal after the long run, but LeBeau got beaten on a simple flag route for a touchdown. With the exception of one terrific game, he has struggled in coverage this year.
PLAY NO. 4: An improvised pitch pass from Legaux to receiver Max Morrison for 22 yards to the Cincy 39.
--LeGaux faked a handoff, ran to his left and threw a long shovel pass to Morrison near the sideline. Morrison ran 22 yards before getting pushed out of bounds by Scofield.
Analysis: Legaux ran right around LeBeau, who could have tackled him in the backfield, before flipping the ball to Morrison. Marley again took himself out of position by running too far inside, giving up the free lane down the sideline to Morrison. No one was there or should have been there. LeBeau needed to blow up that play before it started. Legaux' shovel pass was perfect because it led Morrison into running forward, giving him a head start on the Tulane defense.
PLAY NO. 5: Screen pass to Chase Gladney for a 54-yard TD.
--Cincy lined up with two wide receivers on each side of the field and a running back. Gladney, who was behind the line of scrimmage to the far left, ran a shallow cross behind and past Marley, who was beaten easily in zone coverage, then slowed down to point to a teammate, taking himself out of any chance to make a play downfield. Scofield took a bad angle coming up to stop Morrison as he headed to the Tulane sideline, underestimating his speed. Morrison got by him untouched near the 35, raced to the 10, then cut inside of Nickerson with the help of a blocker in front of him. Scofield tackled him as he crossed the goal line for a touchdown.
Analysis: Too easy. It was nice play that took advantage of Marley's coverage weakness while none of Tulane's pass rusher got any penetration. Scofield, who did not have one of his better games (though still making seven tackles), got caught flat-footed. Nickerson was the last line of defense, but as good as he is in coverage, he is Tulane's worst tackler in the secondary.
So in three possessions with Legaux at QB, Cincinnati had five gains of 20 yards of more to take a quick 17-0 lead.
PLAY NO. 6: Bonne 33-yard run to the Tulane 33.
--After Tulane scored back to back TDs at the start of the second half to cut the deficit to 24-14, this play was a killer. On third-and-1 at the start of Cincy's next drive, Boone took a handoff and ran right around left tackle with nobody there. Royce LaFrance, who spent almost the entire first half on the sideline, got pinned inside along with Williams, who lined up outside of him. LeBeau, who had a rough night, ran up the middle and took himself out of the play. Moore then made a nifty cut outside of Doss, who could have held him to a 12-yard gain, and took off down the field. Nixon, who clearly is the fastest defender on the roster, caught him from behind and tackled him.
Analysis: Nothing terrible here, just Tulane selling out to stop what it thought would be a run up the middle and getting burned by a very good running back. Doss, who had a forgettable night, could have helped out by making his tackle, but Boone was pretty good in the open field. Williams had a rough night as well, getting pushed backward two plays later as Boone gained 8 yards on second-and-10. Williams needs to play hard every down. He's not even close to that yet. Corey Redwine, a name we haven't mentioned much this year in a positive light, made an outstanding play on third down to force Cincy into fourth-and-2, penetrating from his spot at left end to get Boone down on the opposite side of the line. It may have been his best play of the year, but Nixon got beaten on an inside move by a receiver to convert the first down.
PLAY NO. 7: 18-yard TD pass to
--One play after LeBeau made the tackle of the year, lifting Rod Moore up in the air and slamming him to the ground with a perfect form tackle, Lagaux threw a pass to the corner of the end zone that receiver Shaq Washington hauled in with his left hand as he fell down with his back to the back line as Nixon caught up to him and made a nice effortto break up the play.
Analysis: This was an awesome catch. The ball moved a little bit as he rolled out of bounds, but he never lost control of the ball. The call could have gone either way, but I actually agree with Kanell that it deserved to stand. If guys get credit for TDs by sticking the ball a centimeter over the goal line on running plays as they go out of bounds, they should get a TD for making a ridiculous catch in the back of the end zone when the ball moves slightly as they roll out the back of the end zone. Regardless, Tulane's chance to win ended when the replay official refused to overrule the call.
OVERALL ANALYSIS: Cincinnati is a very good offensive team, and Tulane struggles against opponents like that because the offense is not consistent enough to score a lot on bad defenses, which Cincy also has. After two outstanding efforts against UConn and UCF, the Wave played its third worst defensive game of the year behind Rutgers and Tulsa. Too many missed tackles not enough effort on certain plays and the inability of the line to get off blocks were fatal. Obviously, losing Tyler Gilbert hurt because the three-man line of all tackles did not work very well. Ive still not gotten a clear answer as to why LaFrance sat out almost all of the first half, but he didn't play that well anyway when he was on the field.
Tulane matches up better with Houston, which is primarily a running team without the dynamism of Cincy, but the Cougars are better offensively than UCF. Since it's a road game, I'm not that confident Tulane will rebound, but it's possible.