I'm focusing on the option and what didn't work most of the time today, but with some added notes when warranted.
Option 1: A total miscommunication between Cuiellette and Hilliard that was called a pass because the pitch went forward. Hilliard did not even know the pitch was coming until it was in the air and made a nice catch before falling down. for 1-yard loss. Strange deal there. Apparently Cuiellette did not think it was an option play and Hilliard did, so Cuiellette improvised and pitched it to him in the hope something good would happen. That stuff shouldn't be happening in game 8.
Option 2: On fourth-and-1 from the SMU 38, Cuiellette made an outstanding individual effort to pick up the first down when nothing was there and Hilliard was accounted for on the pitch. Cuiellette ran into contact hard and then stretched the ball just far enough to pick up the first down on a play that should have lost a yard. The blocking was horrible.Chris Taylor got beaten. Tyler Johnson blocked someone at least. Center John Leglue blocked no one as he ran downfield.
Option 3: On second-and-10 from the SMU 27, Encalade went in motion as the pitch man but was covered, so Cuiellette, after faking a handoff to Badie, cut up field and gained 11 yards thanks to a nice blocks from Johnson and Medina and an excellent block from Taylor. Cuiellette never will be a great runner, but he's improved and is not as bad as people think in that department. His problem is executing the pitch.
Option 4: After a lost play when Brantley ran to his right like it was an option but did not have a running back behind him, Brantley ran an option to the short side of the field on the right again with Encalade behind him. The spacing did not appear right, and everything was covered as Brantley gained a yard. His series was awful. If that's all they can come up with when he's in there, it's time to file him. It was a wasted series.
Option 5: On first-and-15 from the SMU 32, Cuiellette, running left, pitched quickly to Rounds when a man came in untouched. Tulane did not appear to have enough bodies over there. Breaux and Encalade blocked their men OK, and Medina held up his man, but no one accounted for the safety, who had a clear path to Rounds and tackled him for a 3-yard gain. I didn't see any missed blocks, but there was nothing there.
Option 6: Out of the diamond formation on the next snap, Lazedrick Thompson served as the pitch man running left. No one touched the right end initially as Jacquet, back in at left tackle, ran downfield and barely got an arm on the MLB who ended up making the tackle. Cuiellette cut inside with no room to run outside and managed three yards. Taylor blocked well but got not help from his teammates.
Option 7: Cuillette, running to his right with Rounds as the pitch man, gained 17 yards on nice blocks from Medina and Chris Johnson. Unfortunately, Jacquet wrestled the left end to the ground for an obvious holding call.
Option 8: Faking to Badie, Cuillette ran to his left on second-and-20 with Thompson as the pitch man. Again, the spacing appeared wrong, with Thompson almost in front of him and covered. Cuiellette cut up and was tackled for a 3-yard gain by a pursuing linebacker who was untouched again. That seems to be a recurring problem on the options to the short side of the field.
Option 9: With good spacing between him and Rounds, Cuiellette cut up field and gained 15 yards running to his right. Jacquet sealed the left end, but Sergio Medina, executing a kick out block, grabbed the left leg of a defender and tackled him. I think Cuiellette would have gotten around him without the tackle, so it was a really bad penalty. Chris Johnson did a nice job blocking downfield.
Option 10: On the first play of the second half, running to his left, Cuiellette, with Hilliard as his pitch man, cut up for a 5-yard gain. It was the right decision. Santa Marina, playing left tackle, had a good block.
Option 11: On third-and 3 from the SMU 46, Cuiellette ran right with Badie as the pitch man and got stuffed for a 1-yard loss. This was the first time in this game when Cuielettte absolutely, positively needed to pitch it. No one had Badie, who would have run for the first down and probably gained 15 yards if Encalade had held his block. Instead, Cuiellette cut up with nowhere to go and got tackled by two guys. That's an elementary mistake a QB cannot make on the option. The color commentator was blathering on about it being a bad call, but it wasn't. Pitch the damn ball.
Option 12: I'm not sure this was an option rather than a straight pitch, but Cuiellette took two steps to his right and pitched to Hilliard on third-and-3 from the Tulane 15. Trey Scott made a nice block to allow Hilliard to pick up the first down on a 6-yard gain right before his 67-yard burst. Leglue had the best block on Hilliard's long run, and Tyler Johnson had a good block, too.
Option 13: Running right to the wide side of the field, Cuillette pitched to Badie just before being hit on a play that actually looked like a real option team. No one accounted for Badie, who would have strolled in for a 9-yard touchdown if Tulane had not messed up its perimeter blocking. Medina missed his diving block, so Badie had to outrace a defender to the corner and dive across the goal line. Great blocking initially, and a great run by Badie. Devin Glenn did a decent job holding off his man.
Option 14: On second-and-9 trying to put the game away from the SMU 29, Cuiellette ran to his right with Hilliard as the pitch man. When Hilliard was covered, Cuiellette cup up field behind a good block from Taylor and gained 7 yards. Nice play.
Option 15: Running to his left on the next snap, Cuiellette had nothing. He could not pitch to Hilliard, who was covered, but he should have tried to run outside when he cut. Instead, he went inside and was crunched. He probably would not have gotten the first down going outside, either, because he's not fast enough, but he had no shot cutting inside. Leeward Brown whiffed on his block downfield, allowing a linebacker to fill the hole. The play lost almost a yard and was a really bad moment to have a breakdown.
OTHER NOTES
The INT by Quinlan Carroll was unreal. I haven't seen a Tulane lineman do something like that in the six years I've covered the team. He probably saved a touchdown on a screen that would have worked perfectly against a Tulane blitz, but he leaped in the air, tipped it with his right hand and pulled it in. Man, what a play. The Wave will miss him tomorrow. He also was the guy who ripped the ball out at the SMU 1 in the third quarter. No one remembers the play because SMU recovered it.
Shenall's INT on SMU's next pass was nice, too. He played the route perfectly and was in position to pick off an ill-advised throw that Zach Harris caused with pressure on a delayed blitz. Shenall looks like he's going to be a good player.
Robert Kennedy and Eric Bowie did a poor job on SMU's 22-yard run to start its second series. Smart and Wilson were blocked out of the way, creating a gigantic hole up the middle on the next play, and Jarrod Franklin missed a tackle coming up to fill, springing a 41-yard run. Marley and Marbley were blocked effectively, too.
Smart was blocked out of the play on SMU's 25-yard run that set up the Mustangs third TD, and Marley got clocked as he tried to fill the gap. Shenall did a poor job of getting off a downfield block.
Tulane blitzed effectively all day, something I have not said much in the past. Roderic Teamer was untouched on a sack early. Eric Thomas had a sack on a blitz in the second quarter, and Shenall's blitz led to the second interception.
Marley's height hurt him on the third-and-16 TD pass SMU had late in the second quarter. He was in position to make the deflection, but the ball went over his outstretched hand. That was the difference between an incomplete pass and a 35-yard touchdown. Roderic Teamer did a terrible job of overrunning the play. He should have made the tackle at the 15.
Cuiellette's 33-yard completion to Hilliard down the sideline that set up the go-ahead TD was a play I have not seen from Tulane this year. Hilliard lined up wide right and ran a streak route. Cuiellette's bullet throw beat the safety, who could not get to the sideline in time. Really nice play.
One other thing: the Richard Allen injury is a mystery. He obviously was hurt because he was in a boot all week, but I can't figure out when it happened. He looked fine on the play when he got beaten deep and he looked OK on the touchdown pass, playing the short route when the throw went over his head to Shenall's area in the back of the end zone. I don't know whether he is on the kickoff return team or not, but no one appeared to get hurt there. P.J. Hall replaced him to start the next series, and Allen did not play again.