Of commits and decommits: Who the Heck knows?
- By WaveON
- Joe Kennedy's Wave Crest
- 26 Replies
We’re 25 days away from football signing day and I can’t pin down who is and who is not committed. Kids tweet that they are committed; they respond to interviews confirming their commitment; Coach Fritz tweets his now familiar “Roll Wave!” and you’d think it’s done. Then you notice one day that the kid’s twitter account no longer shows the picture of the “Angry Wave” or the notation, “Tulane Commit.” That sounds pretty conclusive to me. But, the four recruiting sites list wide variations in compiling their committed lists. And determining the reason for a commitment or decommitment is next to impossible.
By my count, we have at least nine kids who committed to Tulane this year and who are no longer committed. This includes Ryan Guthrie who committed one week, visited Syracuse the next, and signed there. Did he just love the freezing conditions and snow storms? Darius Campbell and C. J. Sturdivant were early decommits. They don’t seem to have any P5 offers and I don’t think they’ve committed elsewhere but I don’t know. Kaylan Wiggins, the QB from Florida, decommitted amongst a flurry of accusations that Tulane reneged on his scholarship offer. Again, who knows? Did they simply point out that his potential to play QB was no longer there due to other plans and he felt betrayed? Or did they flat out “yank” his offer? Anyway, he committed to Florida International, not an obvious “step up.”
Evan Reese, DaVontavean Martin, Caleb Sampson, Kris Reed, and Luke McCleary have apparently decommitted in recent weeks and the status of Jataevean Toles appears to be in doubt. And what’s up with Gage Mallory? According to 247, he committed, decommitted, and recommitted all within a six week period back in June-August, but they don’t list him as currently committed and describe his interest as “cool,” even though other sites list him as a commit. At best he’s a very “soft verbal.”
Anyway, with the exception of DaVontavean Martin, none of these guys apparently has received an offer from any P5 schools, though some indicate "interest." What’s going on? My guess is that Tulane has “cooled” on several of these players and whether we “pulled” an offer or pointed out our reduced interest either directly (told them) or indirectly (stopped communicating), they got the message. But, that’s just a guess and not likely to be the universal situation. Some of these kids simply wanted to take a longer look elsewhere. They may or may not return to the fold, if a spot is available by then.
Our long history as a 4th quartile (bottom quarter) football team with losing records against weak schedules clearly harms us. Within Louisiana, peer pressure: “Why would you go there?” is a problem. Almost everywhere, we’re fighting for guys without P5 offers due to the “cache” of playing for a P5 school, and our second-rate facilities don’t help either. Our “game day” experience doesn’t compare to most schools playing BCS football, not just the “big time” schools that draw 90,000 each weekend. We don’t fill a stadium that by most counts doesn’t seat more than 22-25,000 people. Seeing 8-9,000 folks lounging around until half time can’t impress a 17 year old kid.
One would hope that an academic degree from Tulane would be a positive but I’m not at all sure. Kids talk about choosing LSU, Southern Miss, or UAB because of the “strong academics.” What are they thinking? Do they understand what "strong academics" even looks like? And while many of us love New Orleans and couldn’t imagine spending four years in a place like Starkville, Mississippi, the latter appeals to a lot of kids and the former is a turn off. There's a lot to like about a "university town." It’s a personal thing.
I’m still struck by the number of kids who commit to Tulane and call it the “University of Tulane.” I remember when C. J. did that at his first press conference and I cringed. How much research did they do on the school if they can’t even get the name straight? How could they possibly know the "good" that many of us take for granted?
According to Guerry’s recent interview with Coach Fritz, we can expect 22-24 kids to sign on February 1. Hopefully, after this next weekend's visits, we'll start to see the picture clear regarding exactly who they will be.
Roll Wave!!
By my count, we have at least nine kids who committed to Tulane this year and who are no longer committed. This includes Ryan Guthrie who committed one week, visited Syracuse the next, and signed there. Did he just love the freezing conditions and snow storms? Darius Campbell and C. J. Sturdivant were early decommits. They don’t seem to have any P5 offers and I don’t think they’ve committed elsewhere but I don’t know. Kaylan Wiggins, the QB from Florida, decommitted amongst a flurry of accusations that Tulane reneged on his scholarship offer. Again, who knows? Did they simply point out that his potential to play QB was no longer there due to other plans and he felt betrayed? Or did they flat out “yank” his offer? Anyway, he committed to Florida International, not an obvious “step up.”
Evan Reese, DaVontavean Martin, Caleb Sampson, Kris Reed, and Luke McCleary have apparently decommitted in recent weeks and the status of Jataevean Toles appears to be in doubt. And what’s up with Gage Mallory? According to 247, he committed, decommitted, and recommitted all within a six week period back in June-August, but they don’t list him as currently committed and describe his interest as “cool,” even though other sites list him as a commit. At best he’s a very “soft verbal.”
Anyway, with the exception of DaVontavean Martin, none of these guys apparently has received an offer from any P5 schools, though some indicate "interest." What’s going on? My guess is that Tulane has “cooled” on several of these players and whether we “pulled” an offer or pointed out our reduced interest either directly (told them) or indirectly (stopped communicating), they got the message. But, that’s just a guess and not likely to be the universal situation. Some of these kids simply wanted to take a longer look elsewhere. They may or may not return to the fold, if a spot is available by then.
Our long history as a 4th quartile (bottom quarter) football team with losing records against weak schedules clearly harms us. Within Louisiana, peer pressure: “Why would you go there?” is a problem. Almost everywhere, we’re fighting for guys without P5 offers due to the “cache” of playing for a P5 school, and our second-rate facilities don’t help either. Our “game day” experience doesn’t compare to most schools playing BCS football, not just the “big time” schools that draw 90,000 each weekend. We don’t fill a stadium that by most counts doesn’t seat more than 22-25,000 people. Seeing 8-9,000 folks lounging around until half time can’t impress a 17 year old kid.
One would hope that an academic degree from Tulane would be a positive but I’m not at all sure. Kids talk about choosing LSU, Southern Miss, or UAB because of the “strong academics.” What are they thinking? Do they understand what "strong academics" even looks like? And while many of us love New Orleans and couldn’t imagine spending four years in a place like Starkville, Mississippi, the latter appeals to a lot of kids and the former is a turn off. There's a lot to like about a "university town." It’s a personal thing.
I’m still struck by the number of kids who commit to Tulane and call it the “University of Tulane.” I remember when C. J. did that at his first press conference and I cringed. How much research did they do on the school if they can’t even get the name straight? How could they possibly know the "good" that many of us take for granted?
According to Guerry’s recent interview with Coach Fritz, we can expect 22-24 kids to sign on February 1. Hopefully, after this next weekend's visits, we'll start to see the picture clear regarding exactly who they will be.
Roll Wave!!