With essentially no sports going on and this and other Tulane athletic sites either void of any discussion or focused on non-sports issues, I thought I’d take a look at Tulane football coaches during my time as a fan.
I stepped on the Tulane campus in August of 1962 as a true freshman and have followed the fortunes of the Wave ever since. Tommy O’Boyle was starting his first year as Tulane coach and over the intervening 58 years, he has been followed by 13 more. Two coaches, our best (Tommy Bowden) and worst (Wally English) were at Tulane for two years each. Chris Scelfo had the longest tenure, having coached the Wave for 8 seasons. During those 58 seasons, we’ve won 239 and lost 414 and won only 48 games against Div 1 teams with winning records for the season. Bennie Ellender logged 8 of those wins, leading all others. Scelfo won six, and Jim Pittman and Willy Fritz beat five teams each that won more than they lost. O’Boyle and Bob Toledo were the only ones whose squads never beat a team with a winning record. We’ve also had only had 14 winning years during that span. Six coaches had two winning seasons each: Pittman, Ellender, Vince Gibson, Bowden, Scelfo, and Fritz. Two others, Larry Smith and C.J Johnson, had one winning season each. Although Mack Brown was 6-5 in his last regular season, his team lost in the Independence Bowl to finish 6-6. Only Bowden completed his tenure at Tulane with a winning record while Gibson completed his three seasons 17-17. Four coaches, Pittman, Smith, Brown, and Bowden departed Tulane to “greener pastures.” While nine were simply let out to “pasture” (fired). Fritz, of course, is our current coach, who hopefully will join Bowden in the “winners” column and retire with honors from Tulane. While some of our hires have been “head scratchers” particularly in retrospect, most had something in their resumes prior to coming to Tulane that suggest possible success. My view of each of them:
Tommy O’Boyle. (1962-1965) A Former Tulane player, O’Boyle had been a head coach at Southwest Missouri State where he compiled a record of 16-4-1 in two years and then was an assistant coach for a number of years at Kansas State, Duke, and the University of Miami before returning to New Orleans as an assistant to Andy Pilney in 1961. The next year he was named as the head coach, which appeared to be a pretty good hire at the time. His first team, however, which went 0-10, is often cited as the worst in Tulane history but, despite the record, I seriously doubt that. The schedule (Stanford, Alabama, Texas, Mississippi State, Ole Miss, Georgia Tech, Virginia Tech, Tennessee, Vandy, and LSU) feature four top 10 teams plus Georgia Tech who was in the top 20. Once two platoons were allowed by the NCAA, O’Boyle put most of his best athletes on defense and came up with the nickname, “the posse,” whose players sported a hangman’s noose on their helmets. That clearly would not be allowed today. After a 2-8 season in 1965 and an overall record of 6-33-1, culminating in the third of the three 62-0 defeats by LSU, O’Boyle was fired.
Jim Pittman. (1966-1970). Pittman played his college football at Mississippi State where he served as an assistant coach for several years after graduation. He then spent a year as an assistant at the University of Washington before moving to the University of Texas where he coached for the next eight years, the last few as Darrell Royal’s chief assistant. Having played Tulane each of the previous four years at Texas, he knew what he was getting into and he was almost universally hailed as a “great hire” right from the beginning. Pittman’s first year benefited from Tulane’s departure from the Southeast Conference and against a much “dumbed down” schedule, his team went 5-4-1. Still, despite complaints by many fans about the schedule, the Wave beat Virginia Tech (8-2-1), Texas A&M (4-5-1), Virginia (4-6), Cincinnati (3-7), Vanderbilt (1-9) and tied Miami (8-2-1). Losses were to Stanford (5-5), Georgia Tech (9-2), Florida (9-2), and LSU (5-4-1). Today, that would be a formidable schedule indeed. Pittman followed that up with two losing seasons before going 8-4 in the “Year of the Green” in 1970, including a Liberty Bowl upset of Colorado. Tulane’s four losses were to teams with a combined 35-13 record. After the season, Pittman was hired away by TCU where he suffered a fatal heart attack during his seventh game for the “Horned Frogs.” He was known as a very tough coach and I can attest to the harshness of his practices while he was at Tulane. I witnessed them almost daily passing the football field to baseball practice. Hollering, cursing, and blood-letting were common. Quite a few players quit during his first spring.
Bennie Ellender (1971-1975). Ellender was also a very popular hire when he became Tulane’s coach. A QB at Tulane in the 1940’s he came to the Wave after eight years at Arkansas State where he went 52-20-4. In 1970 his team won the College Division National Championship, going 11-0 with Ellender named National Coach of the Year. In his first year at Tulane, the Wave went 3-8 with wins against Texas Tech, North Carolina, and Pittsburgh. An embarrassing loss to William & Mary, being defeated by Rice and Vandy, and being annihilated by Ohio University before the smallest crowd I ever personally witnessed at Tulane Stadium put a damper on the season. Still we played close games on the road against Georgia (11-1) and Notre Dame (8-2) before losing once again to LSU in the season finally. In 1972 we went 6-5 defeating only one team with a winning record but, in a harbinger of things to come, closed out the season by losing to LSU by the score of 9-3, a game which could have gone either way. The following year the Wave went 9-3 highlighted by our first win, 14-0, in over a quarter century against a 9-3 LSU team. Sadly, the season ended in our being routed in the Blue Bonnet bowl by Houston’s veer offense. The next two years Ellender’s teams went 5-6 and 4-7 despite 5-0 and 4-2 starts respectively. The first year’s fall coincided with the season-ending injury to QB Steve Foley and the Wave never recovered. Ellender was fired after the 1974 season, a decision that is still controversial among many Tulane fans
Larry Smith (1976-1979). Larry Smith was our third straight coach with an obviously solid pedigree. Having played football at Bowling Green, Smith immediately went into coaching, first at the high school level and then at Miami U (Ohio), Michigan, and Arizona. Known as a no nonsense defensive coach, he spent his last three years at Arizona as Assistant Head Coach and Defensive Coordinator before signing on with Tulane. At Tulane Smith was very organized and efficient but his first three years yielded a 9-24 record before the “break out” year of 1979 when the Wave behind Roch Hontas, Eric Laakso, Rodney Holman, Eddie Murray and others went 9-3 culminating in a heartbreaking loss 9-6 in the rain to Penn State in the Liberty Bowl. The highlight of the season was a 24-13 win over LSU in a game nowhere near as close as the score. After the season, Smith was hired away by Arizona to be followed by Head coaching stints at USC and Missouri before he retired.
Vince Gibson (1980-1982). When hired by Tulane, Gibson had just completed his thirteenth consecutive season as a head coach in college at Kansas State and Louisville. Although he’d only had two winning seasons in those 13 years and was fired from both jobs, he was fairly well regarded in the coaching profession and was still only 47 years old. Known as “Vegas Vince” because of his gambling style, he wasn’t an obvious hire. His three year tenure resulted in one bowl game and an overall 17-17 record including two wins against hated rival, LSU. Like Ellender’s firing, Gibson’s release is still controversial in some quarters, made even more so by the man who replaced him
Wally English (1983-1984). Wally English played his college football at Louisville and coached in the NFL for five years prior to joining Tulane. He spent five years as offensive backfield coach with the Detroit Lions and was QB and WR coach for two more years with the Miami Dolphins. These probably seemed like good credentials to take over his first college gig and first time elevation to head coaching, but it didn’t turn out that way. English’s tenure at Tulane was probably the most disruptive in the history of the school. It started prior to the first game when a Tulane student, evidently at English’s request, was caught spying on a Mississippi State practice. At roughly the same time, Wally’s son, Jon, transferred to Tulane after stints at Michigan State, Iowa State, Allegheny Community College, and Delgado Junior College. The NCAA ruled Jon ineligible but he sued the NCAA and Tulane to be allowed to play, which he did. His father put him in the starting lineup over Bubby Brister who promptly transferred and eventually spent a long career in the NFL. Eventually English lost his suit and Tulane was forced to forfeit any games they won during his time with the Wave. Compounding the problems, Wally had almost daily battles within the athletic department as he brought in close to 20 junior college transfers, many of whom didn’t bother going to class and, few of whom, ever saw the field of play. He was fired after two seasons and a 7-15 record (not counting forfeits) claiming he only wanted to start winning quickly and the administration hamstrung him at every effort. While the latter has a ring of truth, I personally believe he was the worst coach in Tulane history. Considering some of the competition for that dubious title, that’s saying a lot.