Quick thoughts on Tulane win
- By Guerry Smith
- Joe Kennedy's Wave Crest
- 10 Replies
The conservative game plan worked tonight because UConn is inept offensively, but it won't work against anyone else on the schedule. Tulane will have to open up the offense against UCF no matter who starts at QB. I still prefer a healthy Tanner Lee to Nick Montana, but obviously he would need to play better than he did for stretches of the first four games.
Montana made one great play tonight, getting out of a sack to keep a play alive and finding Justyn Shackleford for a third-down conversion to keep a drive alive that ended in Andrew DiRocco's clinching field goal. Montana also made a couple of nice passes on the opening touchdown drive, but the offense was painful to watch in between. The four holding penalties in a three-possession stretch in the second quarter would have been killers against a better team.
The key for Tulane rebounding from its 2-4 start is the defensive front. Those guys dominated UConn and SLU, and they need to continue to play well against better competition. UCF, Cincinnati, Houston, Memphis, East Carolina and Temple are a lot more dynamic than UConn, but Tulane's secondary is good enough to hold its own against anyone if the Wave controls the line of scrimmage. The Wave almost certainly will be underdogs in every one of those games and needs a run like it had against North Texas, East Carolina and Tulsa as an underdog last season.
UCF is beatable. Again, there's no way I'm predicting a Tulane win on the road against a decent team until after it actually happens, but the Knights have an inconsistent QB and offense in general. If the Wave plays well next Saturday, it can hang with UCF, which easily could have lost to Houston and BYU the last two weeks and could be emotionally flat after getting by BYU in overtime on Thursday.
The most encouraging thing tonight was the special teams. A team can't be functional if it can't make field goals, and DiRocco hitting that 38-yarder was a boost for the entire team. CJ said everyone was jumping up and down like they'd won the World Series when that kick went through the uprights. And Peter Picerelli has an outstanding game, leaping to catch three bad snaps from Matt Marfisi (who ever would have thought we'd say Lizanich can't come back soon enough) and pinning UConn inside its 10 twice. The punt that went to the 1 was one of the five most important plays of the game, leading to the safety that made the score 9-3. But I still can't understand why Dontrell Hilliard is returning kickoffs. He doesn't make anyone miss, ever.
Montana made one great play tonight, getting out of a sack to keep a play alive and finding Justyn Shackleford for a third-down conversion to keep a drive alive that ended in Andrew DiRocco's clinching field goal. Montana also made a couple of nice passes on the opening touchdown drive, but the offense was painful to watch in between. The four holding penalties in a three-possession stretch in the second quarter would have been killers against a better team.
The key for Tulane rebounding from its 2-4 start is the defensive front. Those guys dominated UConn and SLU, and they need to continue to play well against better competition. UCF, Cincinnati, Houston, Memphis, East Carolina and Temple are a lot more dynamic than UConn, but Tulane's secondary is good enough to hold its own against anyone if the Wave controls the line of scrimmage. The Wave almost certainly will be underdogs in every one of those games and needs a run like it had against North Texas, East Carolina and Tulsa as an underdog last season.
UCF is beatable. Again, there's no way I'm predicting a Tulane win on the road against a decent team until after it actually happens, but the Knights have an inconsistent QB and offense in general. If the Wave plays well next Saturday, it can hang with UCF, which easily could have lost to Houston and BYU the last two weeks and could be emotionally flat after getting by BYU in overtime on Thursday.
The most encouraging thing tonight was the special teams. A team can't be functional if it can't make field goals, and DiRocco hitting that 38-yarder was a boost for the entire team. CJ said everyone was jumping up and down like they'd won the World Series when that kick went through the uprights. And Peter Picerelli has an outstanding game, leaping to catch three bad snaps from Matt Marfisi (who ever would have thought we'd say Lizanich can't come back soon enough) and pinning UConn inside its 10 twice. The punt that went to the 1 was one of the five most important plays of the game, leading to the safety that made the score 9-3. But I still can't understand why Dontrell Hilliard is returning kickoffs. He doesn't make anyone miss, ever.