First, I apologize for being absent since Wednesday for the most part. If you check The Adovcate, I wrote 11 stores this week--the most ever--including three on the Saints (usually it's zero), two on basketball, one on baseball and five on Tulane football (counting the advance and Next Level stories that will run Saturday morning). My head was spinning.
Anyway, comparing Tulane to Memphis should be interesting since the Tigers have an outside shot at the college football playoff and the Wave has been one of the worst teams in the country.
OFFENSE
QUARTERBACK
Memphis: Paxton Lynch, a redshirt junior, was a 3-star recruit rated 5.5 but with few significant offers
Tulane: Jordy Joseph, a no-star redshirt senior former walk-on, had an offer from Louisiana College.
RUNNING BACK
Memphis: Doroland Dorceus, a redshirt sophomore, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.3. Jarvis Cooper, a sophomore, was a 3-star recruit rated 5.5. Sam Craft, a junior, was a 3-star recruit rated 5.7 and the No. 50-rated athlete in the country.
Tulane: Sherman Badie, a redshirt sophomore, was a 3-star recruit rated 5.5. Dontrell Hilliard, a sophomore, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.4; Rob Kelley, a senior, was a 3-star recruit rated 5.5.
WIDE RECEIVER
Memphis: Tevin Jones, a redshirt senior, was unrated but in the Rivals database; Phil Mayhue, a sophomore, was not in the Rivals database. Mose Frazier, a redshirt senior, was in the Rivals database but not rated. Anthony Miller, a redshirt sophomore, was in the Rivals database but unrated.
Tulane: Teddy Veal, a sophomore, was a 3-star recruit rated 5.6. Devon Breaux, a redshirt junior, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.3. Rickey Preston, a true freshman, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.4
TIGHT END
Memphis: Alan Cross, a redshirt senior, was not in the Rivals database.
Tulane: Charles Jones, a sophomore, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.2, Trey Scott, a sophomore, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.3.
LEFT TACKLE
Memphis: Taylor Fallin, a redshirt senior, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.4
Tulane: Todd Jacquet, a redshirt junior, was a 3-star recruit rated 5.5.
LEFT GUARD
Christopher Roberson, a redshirt junior, was not in the Rivals database.
Colton Hanson, a redshirt junior, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.4.
CENTER
Memphis: Drew Kyser, a true freshman, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.4.
Nathan Shienle, a redshirt junior, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.4
RIGHT GUARD
Memphis: Gabe Kuhn, a redshirt sophomore, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.2.
Tulane: Chris Taylor, a junior, was a 3-star recruit rated 5.6 and the No. 38 guard nationally.
RIGHT TACKLE
Memphis: Ryan Mack, a senior, was a 3-star recruit rated 5.6. He transferred from Louisville.
Tulane: John Leglue, a redshirt freshman, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.2.
ANALYSIS: Aside from a talented backfield, Memphis has thrived with marginal recruits, including three no-star wide receivers and a line with only one 3-star guy, a 2-star true freshman and an unrated left guard. Tulane's wide receivers were rated higher and three of its offensive linemen were rated higher. Yet two teams cannot be any more different in terms of performance.
DEFENSE
LEFT END
Memphis: Christian Johnson, a redshirt sophomore, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.2.
Tulane: Royce LaFrance, a senior, was a 3-star recruit rated 5.5.
NOSE TACKLE/LEFT TACKLE
Memphis: Donald Pennington, a redshirt junior, was a 2-star recruit from Amite rated 5.4.
Tulane: Tanzel Smart, a junior, was a 3-star recruit rated 5.5.
RIGHT END/RIGHT TACKLE
Memphis: Ernest Suttles, a redshirt sophomore, was a 3-star recruit rated 5.5. Transferred from Nebraska.
Tulane: Corey Redwine, a redshirt senior, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.4.
OLB/RIGHT END
Memphis: Jackson Dillon, a junior, was a 3-star recruit rated 5.5. His other offers were Ark St. and Tulsa.
Tulane: Sean Wilson, a sophomore, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.4. Ade Aruna, a redshirt sophomore, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.4.
WEAKSIDE LINEBACKER
Memphis: Genard Avery, a sophomore, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.3.
Tulane: Nico Marley, a junior, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.2.
MIDDLE LINEBACKER
Memphis: Leonard Pegues, a senior, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.2.
Tulane: Eric Thomas, a junior was a 2-star recruit rated 5.3.
STRONGSIDE LINEBACKER/NICKELBACK
Memphis: Wynton McManis, a senior, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.4.
Tulane: Jarrod Franklin, a redshirt sophomore, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.3.
CORNERBACK
Memphis: Dontrell Nelson, a junior, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.3.
: Chauncey Lanier, a redshirt junior, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.4.
Tulane: Parry Nickerson, a redshirt sophomore, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.4.
: Taris Shenall, a freshman, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.4.
STRONG SAFETY
Memphis: Chris Morley, a redshirt junior, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.4.
Tulane: Darion Monroe, a senior, was a 4-star recruit rated 5.8 and the No. 23 CB nationally.
FREE SAFETY
Memphis: Reggis Ball, a redshirt senior, was a 3-star recruit at outside linebacker rated 5.5.
Tulane: Roderic Teamer, a freshman, was a 2-star recruit rated 5.3.
ANALYSIS: There's no difference. Both teams have two 3-star guys and two 2-star guys on the defensive line, all 2-star recruits at linebacker and one highly rated member of the secondary. In truth. Tulane's defense has played better overall than Memphis, allowing 5.63 yards per play to the Tigers' 5.99.
The gargantuan difference between these teams comes entirely on offense, and although Paxton Lynch gives the Tigers an advantage over almost anyone, the discrepancy in player develop goes much, much deeper.